For legislation relative to clear and conspicucuos price disclosures
SENATE DOCKET, NO. 1603 FILED ON: 1/14/2009
SENATE . . . . . . . . . . . . . . No. 123
The Commonwealth of Massachusetts
Stephen J. Buoniconti
To the Honorable Senate and House of
Representatives of the Commonwealth of Massachusetts in General
The undersigned legislators and/or citizens respectfully petition for the passage of the accompanying bill:
An Act relative to clear and conspicuous price disclosures.
Stephen J. Buoniconti
Susan C. Tucker
Second Essex and Middlesex
Anthony W. Petruccelli
First Suffolk and Middlesex
The Commonwealth of Massachusetts
In the Year Two Thousand and Nine
An Act relative to clear and conspicuous price disclosures.
Be it enacted by the Senate and House of Representatives in General Court assembled, and by the authority of the same, as follows:
SECTION 1. Chapter 94 of the General Laws is hereby amended by striking out sections 184B to 184E, inclusive, as appearing in the 2006 Official Edition, and inserting in place thereof the following 4 sections:-
Section 184B. As used in sections 184C to 184E, inclus ive, the following words shall, unless the context clearly requires otherwise, have the following meanings:
“Advertised price”, the retail price of an item published or disclosed in any circular, newspaper, magazine, television or radio commercial, or in any other medium, or any published correction thereof.
“Automated checkout system”, a cash register, computer terminal, or other device capable of determining the retail price of an item from the item’s code after searching the retailer’s electronic datab ase and printing an itemized sales receipt for a consumer.
“Checkout price”, the retail price of an item charged to the consumer as listed on an automated checkout system display or on an itemized sales receipt.
“Clear and conspicuous”, of such size, col or or contrast so as to be readily noticed and understood by a reasonable person.
“Code”, a unique identifier of an item including without limitation symbols, letters, numbers, bars or combinations thereof.
“Consumer scanner”, an electronic scanner provi ded for consumer use that is capable of reading an item’s code and displaying a description of the item and its retail price after searching the retailer’s electronic database.
“Deputy director”, the deputy director of the division of standards establishe d pursuant to section 5 of chapter 24A, or his designee including, but not limited to, an inspector, a sealer or a deputy as defined in section 1 of chapter 98.
“Discount”, a percentage off or special retail price reflected in the checkout price and indic ated on the itemized sales receipt.
“Display price”, the retail price on a sign affixed to the display on which the unit is placed.
“Division”, the division of standards established pursuant to section 5 of chapter 24A.
“Individual item”, 1 of an item .
“Item”, a specific and distinct product, good or commodity available for retail sale differentiated from another item by having a different universal product code for items so coded, and for items not so coded, an item having any distinguishing characte ristics compared to another item.
“Itemized sales receipt”, a printed sales receipt listing, at a minimum, the retail price charged to the consumer for each item and the quantity sold.
“Price accuracy rate”, the percentage of inspected items for which the checkout price in an automated checkout system is consistent with all other prices represented to the consumer.
“Price list”, an easily referenced list maintained by the retailer that indicates the code, the description and the current retail price of each item excluded under subsection (d) of section 184C.
“Retailer”, includes (i) every person engaged in the business of making sales at retail; (ii) every person engaged in the making of retail sales at auction of tangible personal property whether ow ned by such person or others; (iii) every person engaged in the business of making sales for storage, use or other consumption, or in the business of making sales at auction of tangible personal property whether owned by such person or others for storage, use or other consumption; (iv) every salesman, representative, peddler or canvasser who, in the opinion of the commissioner, it is necessary to regard for the efficient administration of this chapter as the agent of the dealer, distributor, supervisor or e mployer under whom he operates or from whom he obtains the tangible personal property sold by him, in which case the commissioner may treat and regard such agent as the retailer jointly responsible with his principal, employer or supervisor for the collect ion and payment of the tax imposed by this chapter; and (v) the commonwealth, or any political subdivision thereof, or their respective agencies when such entity is engaged in making sales at retail of a kind ordinarily made by private persons.
“Scanner price”, the retail price of an item as displayed on a consumer scanner.
“Seasonal employment”, services performed for wages for a seasonal employer during the seasonal period in the employer’s seasonal operations, after the effective date of a seasonal determination with respect to the seasonal employer.
“Sticker price”, the retail price on a sticker, ticket, tag or other label affixed to an individual item.
Section 184C. (a) The retail price of an item offered for sale by a retailer shall be disclosed to consumers in a clear and conspicuous manner. The retailer may disclose the retail price using an individual item pricing system or a consumer scanner pricing system; provided, however, that an individual item pricing system shall have the retail price of an item affixed to each individual item in a clear and conspicuous manner by means of a sticker, ticket, tag, or other label; and provided further, that a consumer scanner pricing system shall have the code of an item affixed to each individual item in a clear and conspicuous manner by means of a sticker, ticket, tag or other label that can be read by a consumer scanner and automated checkout system.
(b) Each retailer using a consumer scanner pricing system shall have at least 1 operational consumer sc anner at a fixed location. Each retailer with more than 5,000 square feet of retail space shall have at least 1 operational consumer scanner every 5,000 square feet at a fixed location. The fixed location of a consumer scanner shall be disclosed in a cle ar and conspicuous manner. If a retailer provides handheld or cart-mounted scanners, they shall be in addition to those required at fixed locations.
(c) Upon a determination that: (1) a clear and conspicuous sign disclosing the item’s code, its descripti on and its retail price is posted where these items are displayed; (2) the cashier can readily discern the item’s retail price, (3) the retailer maintains an itemized retail price list for all excluded items, and (4) the retail price list is available at e ach checkout and can be reviewed by a customer upon request a retailer may exclude the following classes of items from its individual item pricing system or its consumer scanner pricing system: (i) produce, meat, fish, poultry, delicatessen, bakery items, and any other items that are unpackaged and offered from a bulk display; provided, however, that any such item weighed or wrapped to order by the food store or food department but paid for at a place other than at the point of such weighing or wrapping sha ll have the correct retail price marked on the item; (ii) gallons and half gallons of milk; (iii) eggs; (iv) cigarettes, cigars, tobacco and tobacco products; (v) individual items within a multi-item package, if the package is marked with the correct retai l price; (vi) cakes, gum, candy, chips, nuts and other snack foods, if offered for sale individually, and located at the checkout area; (vii) individual greeting cards, if marked with a price code readily understandable by the consumer; (viii) individual c ontainers of baby food of the same brand and retail price where vegetable or fruit is the predominant ingredient other than water, but not including juices;(ix) soft drink bottles and cans; (x) frozen food products; (xi) items sold by length, area, weight or volume, including without limitation chain, rope, flooring, lumber, fabric, stone or soil, that are unpackaged; (xii) items that must be retrieved for the consumer by store staff, including without limitation large electronics or appliances, display or representative items or items displayed in a locked case or out of reach of consumers; (xiv) packaged self-service items that are small in size and are offered for sale located at the checkout area; (xv) live animals and items sold in a coin operated vendi ng machine; (xvi) items offered temporarily at an advertised discount; and (x) in addition to those classes of items otherwise exempted, not more than 60 items that are: (1) using an individual item pricing system; and (2) accessible to the consumer in a fr ee standing or end-aisle display that has at least 50 individual items of the same item; provided, however, that unless the deputy director determines otherwise, individual items that differ only by color, flavor or scent shall be counted as the same item for the purpose of this clause if they are identical in all other aspects, including retail price, size and brand; and (xvii) not more than an additional 400 items offered for sale.
(d) A retailer shall provide an itemized sales receipt to all customers.
(e) If the consumer qualifies for a discount, the discount or the discounted retail price shall be reflected in the checkout price and printed on the consumer’s itemized sales receipt.
(f) If there is a discrepancy between the advertised retail price, the sticker price, the scanner price or the display price and the checkout price, a retailer shall charge a consumer the lowest price. If the checkout price is not the lowest price or does not reflect any qualifying discount, the retailer: (i) shall not c harge the consumer for 1 unit of the item, if the lowest price is $10 or less; (ii) shall charge the consumer the lowest price less $10 for 1 unit of the item, if the lowest price is more than $10; and (iii) shall charge the consumer the lowest price for a ny additional units of the item. This subsection shall not apply if: (1) there is evidence of willful tampering or (2) the discrepancy is a gross error, in that the lowest price is less than half of the checkout price and the retailer, in the previous 30 d ays, did not intend to sell the item at the lowest price. All retailers shall maintain data on price discrepancies. This data shall be provided to the division upon request. The provisions of this subsection shall be clearly and conspicuously posted by all retailers.
(g) A consumer may submit a complaint to the office of the attorney general or to the division regarding compliance with this section.
(h) If the deputy director determines that a retailer is knowingly or through gross negligence violating sections 184C to 184E, inclusive, the deputy director shall notify the attorney general and the retailer shall be prohibited from using any exclusions under subsection (c) for 1 year.
( i ) The deputy director may require retailers to disclose a consumer’s rights under sections 184C to 184E, inclusive.
(j) The deputy director shall inspect each retailer for compliance with this section. The inspection sh all be conducted pursuant to the national industry standards adopted by the National Conference on Weights and Measures of the National Institute of Standards and Technology. The retailer shall provide the inspector with access necessary to conduct an insp ection. The deputy director shall notify the retailer in writing of violations of this section and shall and any fines imposed pursuant to section 184D section 184E. A fine imposed by the deputy director shall be paid within 30 days of issuance of the noti ce, unless the retailer appeals to the deputy director. If the grounds for appeal are determined to be without reasonable basis, the fine shall be doubled. The retailer shall immediately correct any noncompliance with section 184C when notified by the insp ector.
(k) Any retailer intending to transfer from an individual item pricing system to a consumer scanner pricing system and having a collective bargaining agreement with employees of which item pricing is any part of said employees job responsibilities, shall submit an affidavit to the deputy director prior to the implementation of the transfer stating that protections, including without limitation, a complaint process, are in place so that those employees will not suffer any wage or benefit loss due to said transfer. Said affidavit shall include, without limitation, the number of employees within the bargaining unit holding the collective bargaining unit and the wages and benefits of each employee. If an individual employee’s wages or benefits are reduce d due to said transfer and not due to seasonal employment, the retailer shall disclose retail prices using an individual item pricing system and shall be subject to a fine of not more than $5,000.
(l) The division shall promulgate rules and regulations fo r the administration and enforcement of sections 184B to 184E, inclusive, that are consistent with national industry standards.
(m) The division may retain all registration fees and fines it collects not to exceed $2,000,000 annually. The retained revenu e collected may be used by the division to support its enforcement activities and for grants to approved agents to assist the division in the enforcement of the provisions of this law.
Section 184D. (a) All retailers using a consumer scanner pricing sys tem shall be subject to inspection by the division; provided, however, that the division shall not cause any retailer using a consumer scanner pricing system to be inspected more than once per calendar year; provided, however, the division may inspect any retailer using a consumer scanner pricing system on a more frequent basis if: (1) within the previous 30 days, there is a verified pattern of consumer complaints; or (2) upon regular inspection the retailer is not in compliance with subsection (c).
(b) T he division shall collect an inspection fee from each retailer using a consumer scanner pricing system for each inspection. Said fee shall be $250 if the retail space is less than 20,000 square feet and $500 if the retail space is 20,000 square feet or mor e. Said fee shall be waived if the retailer provided income tax documentation that at the time of the inspection that if during the preceding tax year said retailer had cumulative annual sales revenue of less than 5,000,000 .
(c) A retailer using a consum er scanner pricing system shall be in violation if said retailer: (i) has been found to be not in compliance with section 184C; (ii) has excluded an item under subsection (c) of said section 184C, but has not meet the requirements of the subsection; or (ii i) scores less than a 98 per cent price accuracy rate.
(d) A violation of this section shall be punishable by a fine of $250 for the first offense within a calendar year, by a fine of $500 for the second offense within a calendar year, and by a fine of $1 ,000 for the third and any subsequent offense within a calendar year, up to a maximum of $5,000 per year; provided, however, that the deputy director may reduce any fine imposed pursuant to this section consistent with section 29A of chapter 98.
Section 1 84E. (a) All retailers using an individual item pricing system shall be subject to inspection by the division; provided, however, that the division shall not cause any retailer using an individual item pricing system to be inspected more than once per wee k. The division shall not assess any fee upon a retailer using an individual item pricing system for an inspection pursuant to this section; provided, however, that shall be subject to fees imposed pursuant to section 56 of chapter 98.
(b) A retailer usin g an individual item pricing system shall be in violation if during an inspection: (i) there is no sticker price on an individual item and said item has not been excluded under subsection (c) of section 184C; (ii) the retailer has excluded an item under sa id subsection (c) of said section 184C, but has not meet the requirements of the subsection; or (iii) the retailer scores less than a 98 per cent price accuracy rate. Multiple individual items from the same display of an item which are found in violation o f this section shall be considered 1 violation.
(c) A violation of subsection (b) shall be punishable by a fine of $100 for the first offense, by a fine of $250 for the second offense, and by a fine of $500 for the third and subsequent offense. Multiple f ines issued pursuant to the same inspection shall not exceed $2,500 per inspection; provided, however, that the deputy director may reduce any fine imposed pursuant to this section consistent with section 29A of chapter 98.
SECTION 2. Notwithstanding any general or special law to the contrary, any retailer who, on December 31, 2008, would not subject to sections 184C to 184E, inclusive, of chapter 94 of the General Laws shall not be assessed an inspection fee for any inspections condu cted under section 184D of said chapter 94 until January 1, 2013.
SECTION 3. This act shall take effect on January 1, 2011.
Petitioners: Susan C. Tucker, Anthony W. Petruccelli