SECTION 1:  The tax expenditure commission, established in chapter 68 of the acts of 2011, shall meet on or before June 30, 2017.  

SECTION 2:  Chapter 62 of the General Laws is hereby amended by inserting a new section after Section 64 with the following:

(a)Tax expenditures, as defined by Section 1 of Chapter 29 of the General Laws, created by this chapter on or after January 1, 2011, shall include the following criteria upon passage:

(1)Stated public policy objective for said tax expenditure including, but not limited to, the intended impact of the expenditure with estimates of both the cost and benefit to the Commonwealth

(2)Metrics the tax expenditure shall meet by the date referenced in paragraph (3) of this section

(3)Date by which the legislature shall review the tax expenditure to determine its effectiveness and its cost and benefit to the Commonwealth

(4)An evaluation that considers whether or not a sunset or clawback provision should be applied

(b) Any future expenditure must be matched by the repeal of one or more existing expenditures under Chapter 62 that constitutes a cost to the Commonwealth as determined by the annual tax expenditure estimates required by Section 5B of Chapter 29 of the General Laws that is equal to or exceeds the newly created tax expenditure.  For any unmatched elimination or reduction of expenditure under Chapter 62, the legislature shall consider a corresponding reduction in the rate, as defined by subsection (b) of Section 4 of Chapter 62. 

SECTION 3:  Chapter 63 of the General Laws is hereby amended by inserting a new section after Section 81 with the following:

(a) Tax expenditures, as defined by Section 1 of Chapter 29 of the General Laws, created by this chapter on or after January 1, 2011, shall include the following criteria upon passage:

(1)Stated public policy objective for said tax expenditure including, but not limited to, the intended impact of the expenditure with estimates of both the cost and benefit to the Commonwealth

(2)Metrics the tax expenditure shall meet by the date referenced in paragraph (3) of this section

(3)Date by which the legislature shall review the tax expenditure to determine its effectiveness and its cost and benefit to the Commonwealth

(4)An evaluation that considers whether or not a sunset or clawback provision should be applied

(b)Any future expenditure must be matched by the repeal of one or more existing expenditures under Chapter 63 that constitutes a cost to the Commonwealth as determined by the annual tax expenditure estimates required by Section 5B of Chapter 29 of the General Laws that is equal to or exceeds the newly created tax expenditure.  For any unmatched elimination or reduction of an expenditure under Chapter 63, the legislature shall consider a corresponding reduction in the rate, as defined by subsection (b) of Section 2 of Chapter 63. 

SECTION 4:  Chapter 64H of the General Laws is hereby amended by inserting a new section after Section 33 with the following:

(a)Tax expenditures, as defined by Section 1 of Chapter 29 of the General Laws, created by this chapter on or after January 1, 2011, shall include the following criteria upon passage:

(1)Stated public policy objective for said tax expenditure including, but not limited to, the intended impact of the expenditure with estimates of both the cost and benefit to the Commonwealth

(2)Metrics the tax expenditure shall meet by the date referenced in paragraph (3) of this section

(3)Date by which the legislature shall review the tax expenditure to determine its effectiveness and its cost and benefit to the Commonwealth

(4)An evaluation that considers whether or not a sunset or clawback provision should be applied

(b)Any future expenditure must be matched by the repeal of one or more existing expenditures under Chapter 64H that constitutes a cost to the Commonwealth as determined by the annual tax expenditure estimates required by Section 5B of Chapter 29 of the General Laws that is equal to or exceeds the newly created tax expenditure. For any unmatched elimination or reduction of an expenditure under Chapter 64H, the legislature shall consider a corresponding reduction in the rate, as defined by Section 2 of Chapter 64H. 

SECTION 5:Subsection (b)(4) of Section 14C of Chapter 7 of the General Laws is hereby amended by adding the following “(v) information required by Section 5B of Chapter 29 of the General Laws;”

SECTION 6: The sections of this bill shall take effect on January 1, 2016