SENATE DOCKET, NO. 806        FILED ON: 1/18/2017

SENATE  .  .  .  .  .  .  .  .  .  .  .  .  .  .  No. 1297

The Commonwealth of Massachusetts

_________________

PRESENTED BY:

Cynthia Stone Creem

_________________

To the Honorable Senate and House of Representatives of the Commonwealth of Massachusetts in General
Court assembled:

The undersigned legislators and/or citizens respectfully petition for the adoption of the accompanying bill:

An Act relative to segregation oversight.

_______________

PETITION OF:

SENATE DOCKET, NO. 806        FILED ON: 1/18/2017

SENATE  .  .  .  .  .  .  .  .  .  .  .  .  .  .  No. 1297

The Commonwealth of Massachusetts

_______________

In the One Hundred and Ninetieth General Court
(2017-2018)

_______________

An Act relative to segregation oversight.

Be it enacted by the Senate and House of Representatives in General Court assembled, and by the authority of the same, as follows:
 

SECTION 1. Section 1 of chapter 127 of the General Laws, as appearing in the 2014 Official Edition, is hereby amended by inserting the following definitions:

“Disciplinary segregation,” the segregation of a prisoner from the general population, in a segregation unit or other housing unit, for the purpose of disciplining the prisoner.

“Isolation unit,” a housing unit, segregation unit, or disciplinary unit, including the Departmental Disciplinary Unit, in which prisoners are segregated from the general population in single or joint cells, whether for disciplinary or non-disciplinary reasons, and are not provided privileges and conditions equivalent to the general population.

“Non-disciplinary segregation,” the segregation of a prisoner from the general population, in a segregation unit or other housing unit, for administrative purposes or for reasons unrelated to the enforcement of discipline.  Non-disciplinary segregation shall not include segregation for documented medical reasons or mental health emergencies.

“Segregation unit,” a housing unit, isolation unit, or disciplinary unit, including the Departmental Disciplinary Unit, in which prisoners are segregated from the general population in single or joint cells, whether for disciplinary or non-disciplinary reasons, and are not provided privileges and conditions equivalent to the general population.

SECTION 2.  Said chapter 127, as so appearing, is hereby amended by inserting after section 39A the following section:

Section 39B. Segregation oversight.

A segregation oversight committee shall be convened to gather information regarding the use of disciplinary segregation and non-disciplinary segregation in Massachusetts correctional institutions, jails and houses of correction, to determine the impact of such confinement on prisoners, rates of violence and self-harm within correctional institutions, recidivism, and incarceration costs.

(1)The oversight committee shall consist of seven members: 1 member from corrections appointed by the Department of Correction, 1 sheriff appointed by the sheriff’s association, 1 former judge appointed by the Chief Justice of the Supreme Judicial Court, 1 staff member from the Disability Law Center, appointed by its  director, 1 staff member from Prisoners’ Legal Services, appointed by its director, 1 staff member from the Massachusetts Association for Mental Health, appointed by its director and 1 licensed social worker, appointed by the director of National Association of Social Workers, Massachusetts chapter.

(2)The members of the oversight committee shall be provided full and unfettered access to all Massachusetts state prisons and houses of corrections, and shall be allowed to interview prisoners and staff.

(3)The oversight committee shall gather information regarding:

(i)Criteria for placing a prisoner in non-disciplinary segregation;

(ii)Specialized training provided to staff working with prisoners in disciplinary and non-disciplinary segregation;

(iii) The effectiveness of step-down units to transition prisoners from disciplinary and non-disciplinary segregation to general population units or to the community;

(iv)The effect that reducing the use of segregation has on the rate of prison violence and self-harm by prisoners and on the State’s recidivism rates; and

(v) Other relevant information as identified by the oversight committee.

(4)The oversight committee shall receive quarterly data and statistics from the department and each sheriff concerning but not limited to the following for each correctional institution, jail, and house of correction, and covering the entire quarterly period:

(i)The number of prisoners in disciplinary segregation;

(ii)The disciplinary sentence length of those prisoners in disciplinary segregation;

(iii) The number of prisoners in non-disciplinary segregation;

(iv) The length of time those prisoners have been held in non-disciplinary segregation;

(v)The number of times a particular prisoner has been placed in segregation for that quarterly reporting period;

(vi)The number of prisoners in disciplinary and non-disciplinary segregation, respectively, designated as having serious mental illness (SMI);

(vii) The number of prisoners in disciplinary and non-disciplinary segregation, respectively, with a diagnosed mental illness;

(vii)The number of prisoners in disciplinary and non-disciplinary segregation, respectively, with a significant cognitive impairment or identified learning disability;

(viii)The number of prisoners in disciplinary and non-disciplinary segregation, respectively, who have requested reasonable accommodations for a disability while in segregation;

(ix)The number of prisoners in disciplinary and non-disciplinary segregation, respectively, who have received reasonable accommodations for a disability while in segregation;

(x)The number of prisoners in disciplinary and non-disciplinary segregation, respectively, who have a disability;

(xi)The number of mental health professionals who work directly with prisoners in disciplinary and non-disciplinary segregation, respectively;

(xi) The number of suicides and, separately, acts of non-lethal self-harm, committed by prisoners held in disciplinary and non-disciplinary segregation, respectively;

(xii)The number of planned uses of force on prisoners held in disciplinary and non-disciplinary segregation, respectively;

(xiii)The number of times prisoners held in disciplinary and non-disciplinary segregation were placed on mental health watch and for how long they were on mental health watch status;

(xiv)The number of transfers to outside hospitals and psychiatric hospitals directly from disciplinary and non-disciplinary segregation, respectively;

(xv)The racial composition of prisoners in disciplinary and non-disciplinary segregation, respectively;

(xvi)The number of prisoners in disciplinary and non-disciplinary segregation, respectively, who did not complete high school;

(xvii) The number of prisoners released directly from disciplinary and non-disciplinary segregation, respectively, to the community;

(xvii)The number of prisoners released from disciplinary and non-disciplinary segregation, respectively, within six months of release to the community;

(xviii)The number of prisoners removed from disciplinary and non-disciplinary segregation, respectively, due to mental decompensation;

(xix)The number of prisoners in non-disciplinary segregation who are in segregation for protective custody reasons;

(xx) The number of prisoners in disciplinary and non-disciplinary segregation, respectively, who are lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender, or intersex;

(xxi) The number of prisoners in disciplinary and non-disciplinary segregation, respectively, who are twenty-one years old or younger;

(xxii) The number of prisoners in disciplinary and non-disciplinary segregation, respectively, who are fifty-five years old or older;

(xxiii) The number of prisoners in disciplinary and non-disciplinary segregation, respectively, who are sixty-five years old or older; and

(xxiv)Other relevant data and statistics as identified by the oversight committee.

(5)The oversight committee shall publish a report compiling this information and data annually, with the first report being published within one year of the passage of this Act.  The oversight committee shall make said report publicly available and shall deliver copies of said report to all relevant legislative committees. 

(6)The report of the segregation oversight committee shall offer recommendations geared towards limiting the number of prisoners in disciplinary and non-disciplinary segregation in Massachusetts and ensuring segregation is used as a tool of last resort in narrow, well-defined circumstances.  The recommendations shall include, but are not limited to:

(i)Recommendations as to how the department and each sheriff can adopt a step-down program so that all prisoners in segregation can be returned to general population within fifteen days;

(ii)Recommendations as to steps the department and each sheriff can take to restrict the use of segregation;

(iii) Recommendations as to how the department and each sheriff can ensure that prisoners experience continuity in programming during segregation;

(iv) Recommendations as to how the department and each sheriff can ensure that no prisoners with serious mental illness or who are otherwise considered vulnerable populations excludable from segregation under current law are placed in segregation;

(v)Recommendations as to how the department and each sheriff can deliver meaningful mental health treatment to prisoners in segregation;

(vi) Recommendations as to how the department and each sheriff can limit the infractions resulting in segregation placement; and

(vii)Recommendations as to how the department and each sheriff can ensure that no prisoner is released directly from segregation to the community.