Budget Amendment ID: FY2017-S4-431
EHS 431
Hospital Closures and Health Planning
Ms. Gobi, Messrs. Keenan and O'Connor moved that the proposed new text be amended by inserting after section XX, the following new sections:-
SECTION XX. Section 16T of Chapter 6A of the General Laws, as appearing in the 2012 Official Edition, is hereby amended by striking subsection (a) and inserting in place thereof the following:-
(a) There shall be a health planning council within the executive office of health and human services whose purpose shall be to develop and periodically update a state health plan as described in this section. The council shall consist of the secretary of health and human services or a designee who shall serve as chair, the commissioner of public health or a designee, the director of the office of Medicaid or a designee, the commissioner of mental health or a designee, the secretary of elder affairs or a designee, the executive director of the center for health information and analysis or a designee, the executive director of the health policy commission or a designee and 3 members appointed by the governor, 1 of whom shall be a health economist; 1 of whom shall have experience in health policy and planning and 1 of whom shall have experience in health care market planning and service line analysis.
The council shall assemble an advisory committee of not more than 13 members who shall reflect a broad distribution of diverse perspectives on the health care system, including health care providers and provider organizations, community health centers, academic institutions, health care workforce development expertise, third-party payers, both public and private, consumer representatives and labor organizations representing health care workers. The advisory committee shall review drafts and provide recommendations to the council for the development and each periodic update of the plan.
The council chair shall establish processes to ensure public access to the most current version of the state health plan, and to allow interested persons to submit testimony toward the development and updating of the plan, which process shall include public hearings in geographically diverse areas, and a website to allow members of the public to submit comments electronically and review comments submitted by others.
The state health plan shall identify needs of the commonwealth in health care services, providers, programs and facilities; the resources available to meet those needs; and the priorities for addressing those needs. To assess and report on such needs, the council shall establish not fewer than fifteen health planning regions to reflect variance in the service needs and resource capacities across the different geographies of the Commonwealth. The assessments, findings and recommendations of the council shall be presented according to said planning regions, taking into consideration each region’s chronic disease data, health outcomes data, population characteristics, transportation resources and travel considerations.
SECTION XX. Said section 16T, as so appearing, is hereby further amended in subsection (b), by inserting after the words “primary care resources” in line 50 the following:-
“; community-based health care resources”
SECTION XX. Said section 16T, as so appearing, is hereby further amended in subsection (b), by striking the first sentence of the fourth paragraph, in lines 58 through 62, and inserting in place thereof the following:-
“The plan shall also make recommendations for the appropriate supply and distribution of resources, programs, capacities, technologies and services identified in the second paragraph of this subsection on a state-wide and regional basis, based on an assessment of regional needs and resource capacity for the subsequent 5 years and options for implementing such recommendations, to include the identification of shortage and excess resources in each region and recommended statutory or regulatory mechanisms to incentivize a rebalancing of said shortage and excess resources.”
SECTION XX. Said section 16T, as so appearing, is hereby further amended in subsection (c), by inserting after the word “need” in line 76 the following:-
“pursuant to section 25C of chapter 111 and for making assessments and determinations on the impact of service discontinuations and closures pursuant to section 51G of chapter 111”
SECTION XX. Said section 16T, as so appearing, is hereby further amended by inserting at the end thereof the following new subsection:-
(g) The secretary of human services shall work in conjunction with the agencies and organizations having membership on the council, as defined in the first paragraph of subsection (a), to establish agreements and mechanisms for appropriate sharing of data between agencies as required for the council to fulfill its responsibilities, provided that no such agreement or mechanism shall conflict with state and federal laws and rules for medical privacy.
SECTION XX. Section 13 of Chapter 6D of the General Laws, as appearing in the 2012 Official Edition, is hereby amended by inserting at the end thereof the following new subsection:-
(l) Upon receiving notice from the department of public health of a proposed hospital closure or discontinuation of an essential health service, pursuant to section 51G of chapter 111, the commission shall conduct a review equivalent to that required by this section for a material change, and shall report the findings of such review to the commissioner of public health. The executive director of the commission, and the commissioner of public health, shall enter into a mutual agreement to share documentation provided by the hospital relative to the proposed closure or discontinuation, in order to reduce duplicative reporting requirements by the hospital.
SECTION XX. Section 8 of Chapter 12C of the General Laws, as appearing in the 2012 official edition, is hereby amended in subsection (c) by striking the last sentence of the second paragraph, in lines 50 through 55, and inserting in place thereof the following:-
“The center shall also identify hospitals that the center considers to be in financial distress, including any hospitals at risk of closing or discontinuing essential health services, as defined by the department of public health under section 51G of chapter 111, as a result of financial distress, and shall report a list of such at-risk hospitals, which shall not be subject to disclosure under chapter 66, to the secretary of health and human services, the commissioner of public health, and the executive director of the health policy commission no less frequently than once every 120 days.”
And is hereby further amended by inserting after the word “subsection.” in line 58 the following:-
“Compliance with said reporting requirements shall also be considered a condition of licensure pursuant to section 51 of chapter 111.”
SECTION XX. Section 11 of Chapter 12C of the General Laws, as so appearing, is hereby amended by striking the section in its entirety and inserting in place thereof the following:-
Section XX. The center shall ensure the timely reporting of information required under sections 8, 9 and 10. The center shall notify public and private healthcare payers, including third-party administrators, providers and provider organizations of any applicable reporting deadlines and shall promulgate regulations to establish administrative sanctions against private health care payers, third-party administrators, providers, and provider organizations, including, but not limited to, administrative fines, for any violations of sections 8, 9 and 10. Amounts collected under this section shall be deposited in the Healthcare Payment Reform Fund, established under section 100 of 194 of the acts of 2011.
The center or its designated representative may petition the superior court seeking injunctive relief to enforce the provisions of sections 8, 9, and 10. If the superior court upon summary hearing determines that an entity subject to the requirements of this chapter has, without justifiable cause, refused to furnish information required by sections 8, 9, and 10 or any regulation promulgated by the center thereunder, it shall issue an order directing the payer, third-party administrator, provider, or provider organization to furnish the information within 5 business days; and any failure to obey any such order may be penalized by the court as contempt thereof.
The center may refer delinquent entities to the Executive Office of Health and Human Services, with recommendations that the Executive Office of Health and Human Services impose any penalty authorized under chapters 111 and 118E of the General Laws or other applicable regulations.
SECTION XX. Section 51 of Chapter 111, as amended by chapter 402 of the Acts of 2014, is hereby amended by inserting after the second paragraph the following new paragraph:-
“Each hospital licensee shall comply with the uniform reporting requirements to the center for health information and analysis, as established pursuant to chapter 12C.
SECTION XX. Section 51G of Chapter 111 of the General Laws, as appearing in the 2012 Official Edition, is hereby amended by striking subsection (4) and inserting in place thereof the following subsection:-
(4) (a) Any hospital shall give notice to the department 90 days prior to the discontinuance of any essential health service provided therein. The department shall by regulation define “essential health service” for the purposes of this section, and may establish distinct definitions for each health planning region as defined pursuant to section 16T of chapter 6A. The hospital proposing the discontinuance shall provide, with their initial notice to the department, evidence of having given public notice and notice to municipal officials and of having allowed reasonable opportunity for official and for public comment from each municipality to which it provides the service as a health care resource, as determined pursuant to section 16T of chapter 6A of the General Laws. Any information given without meeting the requirements of this paragraph shall not constitute notice to the department for the purpose of establishing the earliest date on which the hospital discontinue the essential health service. The department shall forward any notice received under this section to the Secretary of Labor and Workforce Development and to the Health Policy Commission.
(b) Any hospital shall give notice to the department 120 days prior the closure of the hospital. The hospital undergoing the closure shall provide, with their initial notice to the department, evidence of having given public notice and notice to municipal officials and of having allowed reasonable opportunity for official and for public comment from each municipality to which it provides the service as a health care resource, as determined pursuant to section 16T of chapter 6A of the General Laws. Any information given without meeting the requirements of this paragraph shall not constitute notice to the department for the purpose of establishing the earliest date on which the hospital may close. The department shall forward any notice received under this section to the Secretary of Labor and Workforce Development and to the Health Policy Commission.
(c) The department shall, in the event that a hospital intends to close or proposes to discontinue an essential health service or services, determine whether any closed or discontinued services are necessary for preserving access and health status in the hospital’s service area, require hospitals to submit a plan for assuring access to such necessary services following the hospital’s closure or discontinuation of the service, and assure continuing access to such services in the event that the department determines that their closure will significantly reduce access to necessary services. If the hospital’s plan for assuring continued access to a necessary service relies upon the availability of similar services at another hospital or health facility with which it does not share common ownership, the department shall require the hospital to submit with said plan a statement from each other hospital or health facility listed in the plan, affirming their capacity to provide continued access as described in the plan. The department shall conduct a public hearing prior to a determination on the closure of said essential services or of the hospital.
(d) The department, in conducting any assessment and prior to making any determination pursuant to paragraph (c), shall refer to the state health plan and regional considerations established pursuant to section 16T of chapter 6A, and shall also request and consider information presented by the Health Policy Commission pursuant to section 13 of chapter 6D.
(e) If a hospital closes or discontinues an essential health service without a plan approved by the department pursuant to paragraphs (a) and (b) of this section, that hospital shall not be eligible to have an application approved pursuant to section 25C for a period of two years from the date the service is discontinued, or until the essential health service is restored, or until such time as the department is satisfied that a plan is in place that, at the time of the discontinuance, would have met the requirements of paragraph (b). If a closed hospital is part of a network of hospitals under common ownership, the same restrictions shall apply against every hospital remaining in operation by the hospital network. The commissioner may waive a restriction established pursuant to this subsection, if the application of such restriction causes an imminent hazard to the public health.
(f) If a hospital executes a plan to discontinue an essential health service, said plan not having been approved by the department pursuant to paragraphs (a) and (b) of this section, that hospital shall not be eligible to receive funding under sections 2PPP or 2GGGG of Chapter 29, or under section 2G of Chapter 111, for a period of two years from the date the service is discontinued, or until the essential health service is restored, or until such time as the department is satisfied that a plan is in place that, at the time of the discontinuance, would have met the requirements of paragraph (b). If a closed hospital is part of a network of hospitals under common ownership, the same restrictions shall apply against every hospital remaining in operation by the hospital network. The commissioner may waive a restriction established pursuant to this subsection, if the application of such restriction causes an imminent hazard to the public health.
(g) No original license shall be granted to establish or maintain an acute-care hospital, as defined by section 25B, unless the applicant submits a plan, to be approved by the department, for the provision of community benefits, including the identification and provision of essential health services. In approving the plan, the department may take into account the applicant’s existing commitment to primary and preventive health care services and community contributions as well as the primary and preventive health care services and community contributions of the predecessor hospital. The department may waive this requirement, in whole or in part, at the request of the applicant which has provided or at the time the application is filed, is providing, substantial primary and preventive health care services and community contributions in its service area.
SECTION XX. Section 56 of Chapter 111 of the General Laws, as appearing in the 2012 Official Edition, is hereby amended by inserting after the second sentence the following new sentence:-
Whoever, being licensed under section 51, discontinues an essential health service or closes a hospital under said license and in violation of section 51G shall, for a first offense, be punished by a fine of not more than $150,000 and for a subsequent offense by a fine of not more than $300,000 or by imprisonment for not more than two years or both. Any licensee under section 51 that closes a hospital under said license and in violation of section 51G shall be punished by a fine of not more than $500,000 or by imprisonment for not more than two years or both, provided that if a closed hospital is part of a network of hospitals under common ownership the penalties herein described shall be levied against the authority, entity or corporation having control of the hospital network.