Amendment #1 to H4989

Modernizing Participation in Public Meetings

Mr. Cabral of New Bedford moves to amend the bill, as amended, by inserting after Section 17 the following ten sections:-

“SECTION 17A. Section 18 of chapter 30A of the General Laws, as appearing in 2020 Official Edition, is hereby amended by inserting after the word “meeting”, in line 9, the following word:- information.

SECTION 17B. Section 18 of said chapter 30A, as so appearing, is hereby further amended by inserting at the end thereof the following:-

“Remote access,” access through the internet, video conferencing or other video technology that allows the public to view and, when permitted or required, participate in a meeting of a public body remotely from a location other than the meeting location.

“Remote participation,” participation by a member of a public body in a meeting of that public body through internet, video conferencing or other video technology remotely from a location other than the meeting location.

SECTION 17C. Chapter 30A is hereby amended by striking out section 20 and inserting in place thereof the following section:

Section 20 (a) Except as provided in section 21, all meetings of a public body shall be physically open, and remotely accessible, to the public.

(b) Except in an emergency, in addition to any notice otherwise required by law, a public body shall post notice of every meeting at least 48 hours prior to the meeting, excluding Saturdays, Sundays and legal holidays. In an emergency, a public body shall post notice as soon as reasonably possible prior to the meeting. Notice shall be printed in a legible, easily understandable format and shall contain the date, time and place of the meeting and a listing of topics that the chair reasonably anticipates will be discussed at the meeting.

(c) For meetings of a local public body, notice shall be filed with the municipal clerk and posted to the municipal website by the municipal clerk and may be posted in a manner conspicuously visible to the public at all hours in or on the municipal building in which the clerk’s office is located. For meetings of a regional or district public body, notice shall be filed and posted in each city or town within the region or district in the manner prescribed for local public bodies and notice shall be posted on the regional or district public body’s website. For meetings of a regional school district, the secretary of the regional school district committee shall be considered to be its clerk and shall file notice with the clerk of each city or town within the district and the clerk of such each city or town shall post the notice in the manner prescribed for local public bodies, and notice shall be posted on the regional school district’s website. For meetings of a county public body, notice shall be filed in the office of the county commissioners for the county and shall be posted on the county public body’s website, and notice may be posted in a manner conspicuously visible to the public at all hours in the places as the county commissioners shall designate for the purpose.

For meetings of a state public body, notice shall be filed with the attorney general by posting on a website under the procedures established for this purpose and a duplicate copy of the notice shall be filed with the regulations division in the state secretary’s office and notice shall be posted on the state public body’s website, or the website of its parent agency.

The chair of a local public body, a regional or district public body, a regional school district, a county public body, or a state public body may petition the attorney general for the use of an alternative method of notice where the use of a website is unduly burdensome or presents a hardship to the public body or regional school district. The attorney general may prescribe or approve alternative methods of notice where the attorney general determines that the use of a website is unduly burdensome or presents a hardship and the alternative methods will afford effective notice to the public.

(d) (1) All public bodies and state public bodies shall provide for remote access and remote participation at every meeting.

(2) Members of a public body participating physically or participating remotely in a meeting shall participate in the same manner for the duration of that meeting. A public body shall have at least one-third of its members physically present at all meetings and members participating remotely may vote, count towards the quorum, and shall not be deemed absent for the purposes of section 23D of chapter 39.

(3) Members of a state public body participating physically or participating remotely in a meeting shall participate in the same manner for the duration of that meeting.  A state public body shall have at least one of its members physically present at all meetings and members participating remotely may vote, count towards the quorum, and shall not be deemed absent for the purposes of section 23D of chapter 39. All meetings of a state public body shall be video recorded with access to the recording posted on the website of the public body within 10 business days after the meeting.

(4) Remote access allowing the public to view or participate in the deliberations of a public body or a state public body shall be available without any paid subscription, toll, or similar charge. All public bodies and state public bodies shall ensure remote access to meetings is accessible to persons with disabilities and provided in such a manner as to ensure equal opportunity to such persons. Public bodies and state public bodies shall include captioning, which may be provided through automatic speech recognition technology, or other reasonable accommodations if needed, consistent with the American Disabilities Act and chapter 151B to persons with disabilities remotely accessing the meeting.

(5) All public bodies and state public bodies shall ensure that remote participation by members is accessible to members with disabilities and provided in such a manner as to ensure equal opportunity to such members. Public bodies and state public bodies shall include captioning, which may be provided through automatic speech recognition technology, or other reasonable accommodations if needed, consistent with the American Disabilities Act and chapter 151B to persons with disabilities participating remotely.

(e) After notifying the chair of the public body, any person may make a video or audio recording of an open session of a meeting of a public body, or may transmit the meeting through any medium, subject to reasonable requirements of the chair as to the number, placement and operation of equipment used so as not to interfere with the conduct of the meeting. At the beginning of the meeting, the chair shall inform other attendees of any recordings.

(f) No person shall address a meeting of a public body without permission of the chair, and all persons shall, at the request of the chair, be silent. No person shall disrupt the proceedings of a meeting of a public body. If, after clear warning from the chair, a person continues to disrupt the proceedings, the chair may order the person to withdraw from the meeting and if the person does not withdraw, the chair may authorize a constable or other officer to remove the person from the meeting.

(g) Within 2 weeks of qualification for office, all persons serving on a public body shall certify, on a form prescribed by the attorney general, the receipt of a copy of the open meeting law, regulations promulgated under section 25 and a copy of the educational materials prepared by the attorney general explaining the open meeting law and its application under section 19. Unless otherwise directed or approved by the attorney general, the appointing authority, city or town clerk or the executive director or other appropriate administrator of a state or regional body, or their designees, shall obtain certification from each person upon entering service and shall retain it subject to the applicable records retention schedule where the body maintains its official records. The certification shall be evidence that the member of a public body has read and understands the requirements of the open meeting law and the consequences of violating it.

SECTION 17D. Section 22 of chapter 30A of the General Laws, as appearing in the 2020 Official Edition, is hereby amended by striking subsection (a) and inserting in place thereof the following subsections:-

(a) A public body shall create and maintain accurate minutes of all meetings, including executive sessions, setting forth the date, time and place, the members present or absent, a summary of the discussions on each subject, a list of documents and other exhibits used at the meeting, the decisions made, and the actions taken at each meeting, including the record of all votes. Minutes of all meetings, including executive sessions, shall be created, and approved by the following meeting or within 30 days, whichever is later, unless the public body can show good cause for further delay.

SECTION 17E. Section 22 of said chapter 30A, as so appearing, is hereby further amended by striking subsection (c) and inserting in place thereof the following:-

(c) The minutes of an open session, if they exist and whether approved or in draft form, shall be made available upon request to any person within 10 business days. A public body may, within 10 business days, refer the requester to the public body’s website where the requested draft minutes may be found. Within 10 business days of approval, minutes of an open session shall be posted to the public body’s website.

SECTION 17F. Said Section 22 of said chapter 30A, as so appearing, is hereby further amended by inserting after the word “meeting”, in line 60, the following words:-

Within 10 business days of a determination that continued non-disclosure of executive session minutes is no longer warranted, such executive session minutes shall be posted to the public body’s website.

SECTION 17G. Said section 22 of said chapter 30A, as so appearing, is hereby further amended by inserting after the word “review”, in line 69, the following words:-

A public body may, within 10 business days, refer the requester to the public body’s website where the requested minutes may be found if all requested minutes have been released to the public.

SECTION 17H. Section 23 of said chapter 30A, as so appearing, is hereby amended by inserting after the word “violation”, in line 34, the following words: or a civil penalty of not more than $200 against any member of a public body for a third or subsequent knowing violation. A civil penalty against an individual member of a public body shall not be reimbursable with public funds.

SECTION 17I. Subsection (c) of said section 23 of said Chapter 30A, as so appearing, is hereby further amended by striking out the seventh clause and inserting in place thereof the following clauses:- (7) reprimanding a member of a public body; provided, however that a third or subsequent reprimand shall be a public record; or (8) prescribe other appropriate action.

SECTION 17J. Subsection (f) of said section 23 of said Chapter 30A, as so appearing, is hereby further amended by inserting at the end thereof the following paragraph:-

The remedy created hereby is not exclusive but shall be in addition to every other available remedy. In an action brought by 3 or more registered voters, such order of notice may also require the public body to reimburse said voters reasonable attorney’s fees and court costs.

And to further amend the bill by adding the following section:

“SECTION 27. Sections 17A through 17J of this act shall take effect on April 1, 2023.”

Additional co-sponsor(s) added to Amendment #1 to H4989

Modernizing Participation in Public Meetings