Amendment ID: S3178-259-R1
Redraft Amendment 259
Modernizing Automotive Franchise Laws
Messrs. Crighton and Payano move that the proposed new text be amended by adding the following sections:-
SECTION XX. Chapter 93B of the General Laws, as so appearing, is hereby amended by inserting after section 9, the following new section:-
Section 9A. (a) As used in this section, the following words shall have the following meanings unless the context clearly requires otherwise:
“Adverse determination”, a determination by the manufacturer or distributor that the amount to be paid to the dealer is less than what the dealer requested in its warranty or recall claim for reimbursement to said manufacturer or distributor pursuant to section 9.
"Independent mediator'', a person not a party to a dispute who enters into a written agreement with the parties to assist them in resolving their disputes and has completed at least thirty hours of training in mediation and who either has four years of professional experience as a mediator or is accountable to a dispute resolution organization which has been in existence for at least three years, and has some background and experience with motor vehicle warranty claims submitted by dealers to a manufacturer or distributor.
(b) Neither a dealer nor a manufacturer or distributor may bring an action in a court of competent jurisdiction based on an alleged violation of the following sections unless the dispute is submitted to mediation pursuant to this section prior to filing an action in court: (i) disputes concerning the proposed average percentage markups on parts under clause (i) of paragraph (2) of subsection (b) of section 9; (ii) disputes concerning the proposed average labor rates under clause (ii) of said paragraph (2) of said subsection (b) of said section 9; (iii) disputes concerning time allowances for the diagnosis or performance of warranty work under paragraph (3) of said subsection (b) of said section 9; and (iv) disputes concerning warranty service or part recall service claims charged back to the dealer under subsection (d) of said section 9.
Prior to filing an action in a court of competent jurisdiction, the dealer, manufacturer or distributor shall serve a demand for mediation not later than sixty days after the dealer’s receipt of the manufacturer’s or distributor’s adverse determination on the matter being submitted to mediation. A demand for mediation must be in writing and served on the dealer, manufacturer or distributor by certified mail, through a nationally recognized overnight delivery service, or through any method permitted under the parties’ franchise agreement at an address designated within the franchise agreement. The demand for mediation must contain a brief statement of the dispute and the relief sought. The recipient of such demand shall be obligated to diligently participate in good faith in such mediation process. Within twenty-one days after the date a demand for mediation is served, the parties shall cooperate in good faith to select an independent mediator for the purpose of attempting to resolve the dispute. In the absence of an agreement within said twenty-one days, the attorney general shall appoint an appropriate independent mediator within ten days of the request by either party. Mediation shall be conducted and completed within sixty days of service of the demand for mediation, unless otherwise extended by agreement of the parties, and the costs will be shared equally between the dealer, on one hand, and the manufacturer or distributor on the other hand.
Notwithstanding any provision in this section to the contrary, the service of a demand for mediation shall stay the time period for filing any action under section 9, until thirty days after the mediation has been completed. Mediation shall be deemed completed when the mediator has so indicated in writing, which may include a writing sent via electronic mail.
To the extent this section conflicts with any dispute resolution process set forth in a franchise agreement or other agreement between dealer and manufacturer or distributor, this section shall control.
SECTION XX. Section 9 of Chapter 93B of the General Laws, as so appearing in the 2024 official edition, is hereby amended by striking out the word “reasonable” in line 4 and inserting in place thereof the following words:- “”fair and adequate”; and
in said section, as so appearing in the 2024 official edition, by striking out the word “reasonable” in line 60 and inserting in place thereof the following word:- “adequate”; and
in said section, as so appearing in the 2024 official edition, by striking out the words “or unreasonable” in line 71; and
in said section, as so appearing in the 2024 official edition, by striking out the word “reasonable” in line 80 and inserting in place thereof the following word:- “adequate”; and
in said section, as so appearing in the 2024 official edition, by striking out the words “or unreasonable” in line 91; and
in said section, as so appearing in the 2024 official edition, by striking out the word “reasonable” in line 128 and inserting in place thereof the following word:- “fair”.